Opposites attract in this teen romance shaped by immigration, grief, and loss.Susan Thomas and Malcolm Vakil could not be more different. Susan is a shy, bookish Malayali Christian perfectionist who grew up in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia, before moving to Canada for her senior year of high school. Malcolm is a hell-raising Parsi Canadian still reeling from his mother's death, his father's abuse, and his ex-girlfriend's betrayal. Despite their better judgment, the two teens strike up a tentative romance, their feelings quickly deepening from infatuation to true love. But as Susan grapples with her parents' impending divorce and her desire to go to art school and Malcolm confronts his conflicted feelings for his ex-girlfriend and his damaged relationship with his father and stepmother, the two must learn to overcome their insecurities to support each other. The story is told from each of their points of view, and each perspective is nuanced and distinct. Susan's character arc is convincing and compelling, defying her initial characterization as a clichd, overprotected Indian girl. But while the action is fast-paced and the characters refreshingly diverse, Bhathena's (A Girl Like That, 2018) clumsy prose and stilted dialogue limit the narrative's emotional impact. The Parsi elements of the book ring true, particularly refreshing considering how little Parsis are represented in Western YA literature. In contrast, the book is riddled with cultural inaccuracies and stereotypes about southern Indians that unfortunately render those characters less believable.A diverse, entertaining love story that falls just short of extraordinary. (Romance. 14-18) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

Bhathena (A Girl like That) weaves forbidden love and love gone awry into her story of a high school senior adjusting to Western culture. Raised in Saudi Arabia, Susan now lives in Canada with her mother while her father continues to practice medicine overseas. Attending a coed school is a novelty for sheltered Susan, and she soon finds herself drawn to rebellious Malcolm-a friendship she hides from her strict parents, who are getting a divorce. Also a secret are her dreams for the future: instead of fulfilling her parents' wishes by becoming a doctor or engineer, she wants to attend art school. Malcolm is holding on to secrets of his own about his charged relationship with his father and stepmother. The characters can feel clichAcd, but this dramatic romance, told from Susan and Malcolm's alternating viewpoints, authentically traces the teens' gradual changes as they come to terms with mistakes they've made and who they want to be. Ages 12-up. (Feb.) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.

In Jeddah, Saudi Arabia, Susan attended an all-girls school where she excelled in her studies, striving to meet the high expectations of her parents. Now, however, Susan and her mother have moved to Mississauga, Ontario, for Susan's final year of high school. It's all joltingly strange, from the absence of Susan's father, who keeps pushing back his arrival date, to the presence of boys everywhere. One boy, Malcolm, manages to befriend Susan despite her resistance. Malcolm has his own demons, rendering him defiant and academically disengaged. The two make wary progress towards a relationship, with each teen narrating alternating chapters. Both of them are of East Indian heritage, as are many of their friends, and the portrayal of transplanted culture heightens the appeal of their story. Their struggles with expectations and traditions born in a faraway land will ring true for any reader with immigrant parents. At the same time, both Susan and Malcolm bear witness to their own parents' marital failings, in contrast with the stereotype of traditional families. A good recommendation for readers interested in romance.--Diane Colson Copyright 2010 Booklist

Gr 7 Up--Susan was a top student at a private girls' school in Saudi Arabia, but then her strict parents, who emigrated from India, move her to a public high school in Canada. For the first time, she encounters guys, alcohol at parties, and academic struggles. On top of that, Susan is faced with her parents' marital problems. Angry rule breaker Malcolm, born and raised near Toronto, is also of Indian descent. He was crushed by his mother's death and is often in conflict with his abusive father. Clearly opposites, they fall hard for each other, but then a kiss from his former girlfriend splits the fledgling couple. Though they are not speaking, the teens continue working jointly on a benefit concert. At the event, they reconnect cautiously after confronting a group of disruptive, racist rowdies. While they tentatively try being friends, at the end of the book, they arrive at the same local college campus as freshmen. A renewed romance is sparked, which may signal a sequel. Narrators Soneela Nankani and Neil Shah express the range of adolescent emotions and accents with assurance and clarity. Both protagonists mature in understanding their families and themselves. VERDICT, Giving weight to India's diverse religious and regional variations and exploring many classic teen concerns, this audiobook is recommended for public and school libraries.--Barbara S. Wysocki, formerly with Cora J. Belden Library, Rocky Hill, CT